ByGenevieve Van Voorhis, writer at
Game of Thrones, ASOUE, and all things '00s. Twitter: @gen_vanvee Email: [email protected]
Genevieve Van Voorhis

Legen — wait for it — wait, what? Sheldon is actually Barney Stinson in another dimension?!

At least, that's what one fan theorist wrote while Jim Parsons was answering questions backstage at James Corden's Late Late Show. According to the theory, Barney and Sheldon were actually the same person, existing in parallel universes. Parsons couldn't help but notice something uncanny about the connection. The actor told the camera:

"The funny thing about this is I auditioned to play Barney, and felt I was very wrong for it, and almost ran screaming from the room after I auditioned. Like, 'Well I did that and I don't know why.' They actually made me come back in as if they were interested. Not interested enough because the right person got that part, Neil Patrick Harris."

You can watch the whole segment from The Late Late Show here:

See also:

As great as Parsons is, it's hard to imagine him doggedly pursuing bimbos and pining after Robin Scherbatsky (Cobie Smulders). He shot the theory down, but wondered if maybe there was a little Stinson in Sheldon after all:

"I find this fascinating that I have this loose-ish connection to this part, and you've got this theory — that's not true — but you've got that theory at all. Maybe I'm giving that vibe off. Maybe underneath this character I've been playing is a raging horndog and a womanizer."

It's a possibility. 'The Big Bang Theory' [Credit: CBS]
It's a possibility. 'The Big Bang Theory' [Credit: CBS]

Parsons wasn't the only person who felt like he wasn't right for Barney Stinson. In an interview with AV Club, NPH reveals that he thought he was all wrong for the role, too, which is loosely based on a friend of the two creators of the show:

"[The pilot script] was clever, but the character was written as a Jack Black, John Belushi type, so I thought, at 6 feet tall and 160 pounds, I probably would not be thought of as that guy... There is a friend of [the creators] that they sort of wrote Barney around, and I met him. He's not named Barney, but he does love Vegas, and cigars, and strip clubs. That kind of guy."

Barney Stinson 'How I Met Your Mother' [Credit: CBS]
Barney Stinson 'How I Met Your Mother' [Credit: CBS]

Clearly, the casting directors at made the right choice. HIMYM went off the air in 2014, but The Big Bang Theory is still going strong in Season 10. Maybe it's not too late for a crossover episode, or at least a little cameo?


Do you think Sheldon might be Barney in a parallel universe?

Check out the promo for the next episode of The Big Bang Theory, which airs Thursday on CBS.


Latest from our Creators