This post contains spoilers for DC's Legends of Tomorrow Season 2.
Legends of Tomorrow wrapped its best season yet with the action-packed Season 2 episode "Aruba." With the team united, they were ready to take off for 2017 when #CaptainRipHunter decided to leave the ship, knowing it was in capable hands with Captain Sara Lance.
Immediately after the episode ended, fans began scouring the internet to find out whether Rip Hunter would return in Season 3. What they found was an ambiguous answer from executive producer Marc Guggenheim, who was interviewed on Entertainment Weekly's Superhero Insider Podcast:
"We’ve got plans for Rip for next year. It’s just in a different capacity than him being a member of the team."
So while it seems #ArthurDarvill, the actor who portrays Captain Rip Hunter, will be returning to Legends of Tomorrow, there's an unanswered question left dangling in the air: is that a good choice?
I personally loved Captain Hunter, and I thought he did a great job assembling the team and getting them to work together — but, after the way he handed the reins over to Sara, a return seems almost anticlimatic. Learning when to let a character go is a major part of what makes a television show great or mediocre, and when a character has served his or her purpose, it's almost painful to watch them being shoehorned into a role that doesn't fit well.
The entirety of Season 1 of Legends of Tomorrow revolved around finding and stopping Vandal Savage before he could kill Captain Hunter's family. That was the reason Hunter gathered the Legends together in the first place. When the storyline wrapped and Savage was destroyed, Captain Hunter chose to save the Legends in the Season 1 finale.
The entirety of Season 2 focused on the Legion of Doom and the Spear of Destiny, and the Legends rallied together to serve a common good, with Sara Lance proving an able and competent leader. Though Hunter was missed, he wasn't needed to ensure the team worked together.
Of course his return was welcome, as both viewers and the team wanted to know what had happened to him, but once again, he served his purpose by helping the team locate the Spear of Destiny. And then he chose a different destiny for himself.
Is it so wrong to allow a character to ride off into the sunset, especially with new Legends hinted to join the team in Season 3? Rip's story ended on a high note when he departed the Waverider, and, perhaps, with new Legends arriving, it's okay for him to seek his purpose elsewhere.
Do you think Legends of Tomorrow bringing Rip Hunter back is a good idea? Let me know in the comments below!