ByKatrina Stagg, writer at
Katrina Stagg

Last week, I published an article naming some childhood crushes we are still smitten with. There was a great response—because let's be honest, crushing is an all-time favorite past time! Many of you responded in the comments about your childhood crushes and I felt it necessary to pay tribute to the young hotties you crushed on that I missed.

Thank you to all that offered your opinions. You each have stellar taste in the babe department! Here is round 2 of celebrity crushes we are still carrying a torch for.

Now for the lovely ladies who set our young hearts a blaze and still keep them smoking.

Alyssa Milano

First crush: Samantha Micelli - Who’s The Boss (1984)

Danielle Fishel

First Crush: Topanga - Boy Meets World (1993)

Winona Ryder

First crush: Gemma - Square Dance (1987)

But we all know It was her role as Lydia Deetz in Beetlejuice (1988) that solidified her place in the Crush Hall of Fame.

Alicia Silverstone

First Crush: Hot girl - Aerosmith Cryin' music video (1993)

Elisha Cuthbert

First crush: Elisha - Popular Mechanics for Kids (1997)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

First crush: Buffy Summers - Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1996)

Michelle Pfeiffer

First Crush: Stephanie Zinone - Grease 2 (1982)

Neve Campbell

First crush: Julia Salinger - Party of Five (1994)

Lynda Carter

First crush: Diana Prince / Wonder Woman - Wonder Woman (1975)

Tatiana Ali

First crush: Ashley Banks - Fresh Prince of Bel-Air (1990)

Kate Winslet

First crush: Rose DeWitt Bukater A.K.A. Rose Dawson - Titanic (1997)

Soleil Moon Frye

First crush: Punky Brewster - Punky Brewster (1984)

Jennifer Connelly

First crush: Sarah - Labyrinth (1986)

Linda Cardellini

First crush: Lindsay Weir - Freaks and Geeks (1999)

Christina Applegate

First crush: Kelly Bundy - Married with Children (1987)

Elizabeth Montgomery

First crush: Samantha Stephens - Bewitched (1964)

Elizabeth Montgomery's role as Samantha Stephens stole the hearts of multiple generations. Montgomery passed away in May of 1995 from cancer but will continues to be a bewitching part of our youth and lives.

Now for the man crushes!

Mark-Paul Gosselaar

First crush: Zach Morris - Good Morning, Miss Bliss (1988) & Saved by the Bell (1989)

Jason David Frank

First crush: Tommy Oliver / The White Ranger / The Green Ranger - Mighty Morphin Power Rangers (1993)

Neil Patrick Harris

First crush: Dr. Doogie Howser - Doogie Howser, M.D. (1989)

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

First crush: Randy Taylor - Home Improvement (1991)

Freddie Prinze Jr.

First crush: Ray Bronson - I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997)

Johnny Depp

First crush: Officer Tom Hanson - 21 Jump Street (1987)

Devon Sawa

First crush: Junior - Little Giants (1994)

Joey Lawrence

First Crush: Joey Russo - Blossom (1990)


Latest from our Creators