ByWilliam Cloud, writer at Creators.co
If's there's a fandom, there's a good chance that I'm a part of it. On Instagram: @thewillcloud On Twitter: @thewccloud
William Cloud

As humans, we constantly make comparisons. One of those things that geeks especially love to compare and contrast are comic book characters, and because there are basically two 'big' publishing companies it is even easier to compare two characters with each other. Batman gets this treatment a lot with many of Marvel's heroes. However, does the Dark Knight truly have a counterpart in Marvel comics? I'm going to deal with five characters and compare them to Batman, to see if we indeed have a comparable hero to the Caped Crusader in Marvel.

First, let's lay down the basics for who and what Bruce Wayne is.

  • Born into an extremely rich family
  • Parents murdered at young age
  • Traveled the world gaining knowledge and skills
  • Returned home and began to fight for justice
  • Is a symbol of fear
  • Is the world's foremost combatant and detective
  • Is extremely adept at hand-to-hand combat and uses gadgets
  • Appears to be flamboyant, but is not
  • Is in his mid-30's in most stories
  • Creates most of his enemies
  • Is the symbol of DC comics

I could go into more details, but I think that this is a good base on which to begin. And begin we shall, with an unlikely character.

Spider-Man

I know what you're thinking: "That's crazy!" Well, check out my friend Ian Simpson's article on the subject. I'm going to focus on comparing the two via my list:

  • Born into a middle-class family
  • Parents killed at a young age (Not Uncle Ben, but his real parents)
  • Gains powers through a spider bite
  • Begins to fight for justice
  • Is a symbol of youth and goodness
  • Is a brilliant scientist and photojournalist
  • Is very acrobatic and uses gadgets
  • Is a complete nerd
  • Is high-school to college age in his stories
  • Most of his enemies are already in existence
  • Is one of many famous Marvel characters

Spider-Man and Batman have some similarities, including the name. However, you have a great number of differences. Spider-Man isn't rich, and is much younger. He doesn't have the fighting skills, and though he has used fear tactics before, he's never been a symbol of terror. Both men are vigilantes, but the differences between the two are vast.

Iron Man

Here's one that's thrown around a little more often. Both are rich, both drive fancy cars...but are they really anything like each other? Remember that I'm making lists for these characters in comparison to the list I made about Batman.

  • Born into an extremely rich family
  • Parents killed at a young age
  • Captured by terrorists and forced to build the Mk. I
  • Returns home and builds advanced tech which he uses against evil
  • Is a symbol of extravegance
  • Is the world's foremost engineer and inventor
  • Uses a suit of high-tech armor and an AI system
  • Appears to be flamboyant, and is
  • Is in his mid-30's in most stories
  • Most enemies try to copy his weaponry
  • Is probably the closest character to a poster child

Tony Stark and Bruce Wayne are rich and have fancy toys. That's about as similar as they are. Tony has no fighting skills and is as drunk as he appears to be. Bruce doesn't rely on the armor (unless he fights Superman) that Stark has. And while Batman fights for justice and a better city, Iron Man fights for himself.

Moon Knight

A lot of people make comparisons between the Dark Knight and the Moon Knight because of their gritty personas, but let's see how Marc Spector matches up with Bruce Wayne

  • Born into a poor family
  • Left his family to join the CIA
  • Was killed as a mercenary, but was resurrected by Khonshu
  • Returns home and begins fighting for vengance
  • Is a symbol of fear
  • Is a world-renowned combatant
  • Has god-like powers, impressive combat knowledge and uses gadgets
  • Is extremely serious
  • Is in his mid-20's in most stories
  • Most enemies already exist
  • Is more obscure in Marvel comics

If Batman was a part of Justice League Dark, then the comparison would be more complete. Moon Knight has strong ties to the magical world thanks to Khonshu. He's not wealthy, and fights because he was commanded by his 'god' to do so. His skills and persona make him more similar than our other two, however.

Black Panther

T'Challa is often compared to Batman because of their prowess in both stealth and combat, as well as their intellect. However, I believe that there are some pretty big differences.

  • Born into a royal family
  • Parents killed at a young age
  • Gained his knowledge through his ancestors
  • Fights to defend his homeland and the world
  • Is a symbol of royalty
  • Is a world-famous combatant and diplomat
  • Is extremely well versed in hand-to-hand combat and retains ancestors' wisdom
  • Acts in a kingly manner
  • Is in his mid-20's for most stories
  • His enemies are already in existence
  • Is a well-known Marvel character

Once again, you have a character whose ties to magic are stronger than Batman. And while Bruce is diplomatic, he's no king. T'Challa is a superior in all respects, save skills and backstory. Though they are both masters of stealth, their methods are very different.

The Punisher

Though Frank Castle uses guns, the two men have often been compared thanks to their dark natures and skill in fights. Do they match up well? Let's see.

  • From a middle-class family
  • Family killed by the Mob
  • Gained skills from service in Vietnam and Special Forces
  • Fights to avenge his wife and children
  • Is a symbol of vengeance
  • Is a master strategist
  • Is extremely knowledgeable with weapons and hand-to-hand combat
  • Is very solemn
  • His enemies are usually normal human beings
  • Is a well-known Marvel character

Frank uses guns. That's the biggest difference between the Punisher and the Batman. Castle also doesn't have the intellect or the resources that Bruce Wayne does, nor does he have the range of fighting skills.

In conclusion, is there anyone that compares to Batman? Not really. There are similarities, and points that are equal, but Bruce Wayne is his own unique person. In the same thread, so are all these others. All of these characters are different and powerful in their own way. Maybe we shouldn't try to compare them so often...or maybe not. What do you think? Did I leave a character or a point out? Let me know in the comments below!

Poll

Which Marvel character do you think is the most similar to Batman?

Trending

Latest from our Creators