ByBill Solo, writer at
Hey, i'm Bill. I like superheroes, space battles and pancakes. Read my posts, if you like, or whatnot.
Bill Solo

The Walking Dead broke hearts and records when they showed the famed comic book villain Negan, in the season 6 finale of the show, and someone was gonna get Lucilled, and then that despised cliff-hanger was pulled where we have to wait till the next season to find out who got the bat in the head.

Here's my answer:


Now, i know they made fans believe Daryl died in the last episode, but NO, and he's in the line-up as well, and the clues are

  • Daryl did kill some of Negan's men
  • When Negan says 'Takin' it like a champ' he's a tough guy, so he could take it, even shot.
  • You can hear a grunt or pain sound from what looks to be Norman Reedus
  • Rick's and Carl's screams
  • His time is done
  • Norman Reedus has a new show, and can't shoot TWD
  • Maybe Negan thought to put him out of his misery because of the wound

That's the evidence that do prove Daryl might have got Lucilled.

Oh well, just look at this video, that might provide enough evidence to say that it's probably Glenn.

And here's an open letter to Scott M. Gimple, which sums up all of our feelings towards that bullshit ending:


Dear Mr. Gimple, Hey there, Friendo! How were your Rice Krispies this morning? Mine were disappointing. A disappointing mess that started out full of promise with crispy, golden puffs that snapped and crackled, but then slowly deteriorated to soggy nothingness. I stirred around said puffs for 90 minutes only to realize in the last few minutes I wasn’t going to eat the Rice Krispies. Oh I wanted to. They were glistening. They were lightly sweetened and fizzling. I had promised myself and all those around me that I. Would. Eat. Those. Rice Krispies. I hyped. I buzzed. I brought all Rice Krispies fans to the brink. But for no logical reason, I just decided to put them back in the refrigerator. I’ll check on them again in about 7 months. By then the Krispies will just all be dissolved into a mushy glob and I won’t care about them at all. But that’s okay. I’ll just pour myself some Bitchnuts. Screw those Krispies. I’m not a casual viewer. I’m not a so-called ‘rabid’ fan, either. I’m somewhere on the outside longing for good storytelling, intense performances, creative special effects and because of…reasons…I have a special insight into what’s going to happen on this show. I do not have difficulty grasping foreshadow or innuendo, I absorb details, am able to insert complicated, character puzzle pieces into place, and I understand implication. What I don’t understand is why you and your fellow writers continue to treat fans such as myself as starry-eyed, catatonic, fanboyz/gurlz, to such an extent that you become completely disconnected from your duty as a storyteller? You have no idea who your audience is anymore. Like Negan, you have become the star of your own movie. A movie that may have gotten good reviews on its first weekend at the box office, but continues to dream up more far-fetched and illogical contrivances that botch it every time a sequel hits the screen. You are the Batman v. Superman of the Justice League movies. The purpose of a cliffhanger is so the audience will be excited for what happens next. Audiences crave resolution. However, in this case, the audience already knows what’s going to happen. (Remember the graphic novel?) We all know one of our favorite characters has been bludgeoned to death by a barbed wire bat attached to the hand of an alarmingly sexy psychopath. So why? What was the storytelling purpose of adding this tired, television ratings grabbing device to this episode? I just want an honest reason. If it’s ratings – just say it. Don’t wrap it in fluff. It would be better than wasting time listening to nonsensical comparisons to Lost and the mysterious hatch. (By the way, that comparison was not on point. That Lost finale left the audience excited to find out what wonderous things were in the hatch and set a clear delineation in the story. All you did is piss people off. All they have to look forward to is the bloody mess of a bludgeoned, beloved character that they know damned well has already been murdered, lying in the dirt in front of the RV.) Definitely do not compare yourself to the Game of Thrones showrunners. Their season ended on a cliffhanger at the same point the source material did. There is a world of difference there. I don’t buy your whole “end of Rick’s story” nincompoop. The entire series is Rick’s story. In every single episode Rick ends up somewhere different than when he started. We all saw the defeat in Rick’s eyes, but you didn’t let him feel or emote the effects of Lucille and you didn’t let us see it either. That’s still part of this story arc. That is the comeuppance of this first meeting with Negan and you blew it. There was no conclusion. What you haven’t mastered is layering an arc to its natural precipice and then then designing the payoff to fulfill the audience while maintaining the story and character’s integrity. Forget promising to deliver a story in a new episode that justifies a previous one. A good showrunner doesn’t need to justify or defend prior episodes, he or she only needs to progress the story further, develop characters and convince the audience to come along for the ride. How do you expect your audience to follow you down the rabbit hole when they have already spent months invested in a character’s journey only to find out you care less about it than they do? A show should not need an hour long talk show after each episode to explain what happened in it. It shouldn’t need website bios to fill in time gaps. Get out of your own way, Gimple. Maybe it’s possible that you’ve forgotten who you write this show for. Is it to enlarge Kirkman’s ego? Is it to satisfy money-grubbing producers? Or is it for the audience? The better question is, do you write it this story in a way that does justice to the story? Because the story exists already. Like it or not, this show does have a basis in printed canon. (By the way, issue 100 didn’t end on a cliffhanger.) Your actors are doing it justice. Andrew Lincoln is Rick Mother Fucking Grimes. Danai embodies embattled but hopeful Michonne. Steven’s emotional performances are second to none. Melissa McBride’s portrayal of Carol is so understated and mesmerizing. Let’s not forget Jeffrey Dean Morgan. Just – wow. I’m giving him and the casting department credit for that one, though. He nailed the monologue that Kirkman wrote (yeah, Kirkman, not you). Everyone else on the cast has grown and improved due to the bar being raised by the actors working alongside them and I truly appreciate even the most minor of characters. Even Nicholas made me love to hate him. But you just kicked them all in the balls, Gimple. I feel really sorry for the cast who now has to feel the backlash of your decisions and whose performances are overshadowed by the sheer ego you have displayed. You’re not Abrams, man. I don’t think you’re the visionary you think you are. You’re not learning from your previous mistakes. During this writing, I was blessed to read your press conference responses regarding your creative decisions. You all but insulted the entire fan base. Stop talking down to your audience and telling us that how we feel about your storytelling is just our cynical minds. The so-called skeptics that you are condescending to have given you ratings season after season. Insulting us does not exemplify your “caring” about the audience. It’s the exact opposite. We gave you the benefit of the doubt during the Governor’s two-week pity party, we gave you the benefit of the doubt that the Grady Hospital of Sadists actually had a purpose, we gave you the benefit of the doubt when you presented the mid-season finale as a cliffhanger, just to gloss over the aftermath and the grief of the characters in the following episodes. And we’re supposed to think that’s all going to change now? The script is written already. How long are we supposed to wait to grasp your brilliance? Stop telling us you’re going to make it great. It should be great, or at least understandable, to begin with. Gimple: “The hard thing about it is you can’t say why you do some of the turns you take because you’ll wind up telling details of the story. I do know the writers and producers and cast and crew know why we do what we do. We know our intentions are good. We care about our audience and we’re just trying to deliver them an experience.” Sorry, but the writers and producers are not the people you need to make believe in your story, it’s the audience. The audience should know the details of the story. They shouldn’t have to watch a talk show to get them or have to listen to endless pleas of “trust me.” If you can’t convey your “why,” in your episodes (which is part of the experience), then you’re just not a good showrunner. Didn’t someone, somewhere along the line say, “Uhh, Scott? Yeah, ummm, I was just thinking…. ummm….the fans already know Negan’s coming because you know, it’s a book and all, and because we’ve been doing all these interviews and stuff and telling them how shocking it’s gonna be and how the actors can’t sleep and were sick to their stomachs and all, and so…. I don’t think it’s a good idea to be lying to our fan base and let our entire audience fester in anger for six months because you know that the spoilers are gonna leak during filming anyway so what’s the point? And by that time, they won’t even care who died.” Yes. Yes, I’m sure someone said that to you. Maybe a production assistant? Somebody in Craft Services? Although I am someone who dedicates countless hours to this show, albeit not in the same way any of the cast or crew do, I don’t necessarily feel entitled to this opinion nor do I expect you to even give it one ounce of consideration. You’ve made it clear that this “intelligent” audience just doesn’t ‘get you.’ But I am compelled to voice this opinion on behalf of thousands of fans just like me who have been loyal and steadfast, discerning, and deserving of those promises you casually hand out, but never fulfill. ~ A Fan of The Walking Dead.

That was beautiful.

Who do you think got killed by Negan? Post your theories below?


Latest from our Creators